Butt Plugs

140 Products
Pretty Love Morton Plug Purple
Pretty Love Morton Plug Purple
Pretty Love Morton Plug Purple
Pretty Love Morton Plug Purple
Pretty Love Morton Plug Purple
Pretty Love Morton Plug Purple
Pretty Love Morton Plug Purple
Pretty Love
Pretty Love Morton Plug Purple
$71.99 $89.99
SALE
Adam & Eve Clear Gem Anal Plug Large
Adam & Eve
Adam & Eve Clear Gem Anal Plug Large
$43.99 $54.99
SALE
Evolved Black Gem Anal Plug Set 3pk
Evolved Black Gem Anal Plug Set 3pk
Evolved Black Gem Anal Plug Set 3pk
Evolved Black Gem Anal Plug Set 3pk
Evolved Black Gem Anal Plug Set 3pk
Evolved
Evolved Black Gem Anal Plug Set 3pk
$115.99 $144.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Adam & Eve Red Heart Anal Plug Large
Adam & Eve Red Heart Anal Plug Large
Adam & Eve Red Heart Anal Plug Large
Adam & Eve Red Heart Anal Plug Large
Adam & Eve Red Heart Anal Plug Large
Adam & Eve Red Heart Anal Plug Large
Adam & Eve Red Heart Anal Plug Large
Adam & Eve Red Heart Anal Plug Large
Adam & Eve
Adam & Eve Red Heart Anal Plug Large
$55.99 $69.99
SALE
Forto F-35R Rattler T Plug One Size Black
Forto F-35R Rattler T Plug One Size Black
Forto F-35R Rattler T Plug One Size Black
Forto
Forto F-35R Rattler T Plug One Size Black
$59.99
Sweet Treat
Sweet Treat
Sweet Treat
Sweet Treat
Evolved
Sweet Treat
$36.79 $45.99
SALE
Playboy Pleasure Tux Plug Small
Playboy Pleasure Tux Plug Small
Playboy Pleasure Tux Plug Small
Playboy Pleasure Tux Plug Small
Playboy Pleasure Tux Plug Small
Playboy Pleasure Tux Plug Small
Playboy
Playboy Pleasure Tux Plug Small
$51.19 $63.99
SALE
Playboy Pleasure Tux Plug Large
Playboy Pleasure Tux Plug Large
Playboy Pleasure Tux Plug Large
Playboy Pleasure Tux Plug Large
Playboy Pleasure Tux Plug Large
Playboy Pleasure Tux Plug Large
Playboy Pleasure Tux Plug Large
Playboy
Playboy Pleasure Tux Plug Large
$63.19 $78.99
SALE
Playboy Pleasure Trust The Thrust
Playboy Pleasure Trust The Thrust
Playboy Pleasure Trust The Thrust
Playboy Pleasure Trust The Thrust
Playboy Pleasure Trust The Thrust
Playboy Pleasure Trust The Thrust
Playboy
Playboy Pleasure Trust The Thrust
$215.99 $269.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Realrock 4.5" Crystal Clear Plug Purple
Realrock 4.5" Crystal Clear Plug Purple
Realrock 4.5" Crystal Clear Plug Purple
Realrock 4.5" Crystal Clear Plug Purple
Realrock
Realrock 4.5" Crystal Clear Plug Purple
$34.99
Realrock 4.5" Crystal Clear Plug Blue
Realrock 4.5" Crystal Clear Plug Blue
Realrock 4.5" Crystal Clear Plug Blue
Realrock 4.5" Crystal Clear Plug Blue
Realrock 4.5" Crystal Clear Plug Blue
Realrock
Realrock 4.5" Crystal Clear Plug Blue
$34.99
Gender X Just The Tip
Gender X Just The Tip
Gender X Just The Tip
Gender X Just The Tip
Gender X
Gender X Just The Tip
$91.99 $114.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Gender X Rockin Metal Plug
Gender X Rockin Metal Plug
Gender X Rockin Metal Plug
Gender X Rockin Metal Plug
Gender X
Gender X Rockin Metal Plug
$147.99 $184.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Zero Tolerance The Emperor Rechargeable Plug with Remote
Zero Tolerance The Emperor Rechargeable Plug with Remote
Zero Tolerance The Emperor Rechargeable Plug with Remote
Zero Tolerance The Emperor Rechargeable Plug with Remote
Zero Tolerance
Zero Tolerance The Emperor Rechargeable Plug with Remote
$111.99 $139.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Evolved Mighty Mini Plug Rechargeable
Evolved Mighty Mini Plug Rechargeable
Evolved Mighty Mini Plug Rechargeable
Evolved Mighty Mini Plug Rechargeable
Evolved Mighty Mini Plug Rechargeable
Evolved Mighty Mini Plug Rechargeable
Evolved
Evolved Mighty Mini Plug Rechargeable
$95.99 $119.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Pretty Love Beaded Butt Plug BI-040052W
Pretty Love Beaded Butt Plug BI-040052W
Pretty Love Beaded Butt Plug BI-040052W
Pretty Love Beaded Butt Plug BI-040052W
Pretty Love Beaded Butt Plug BI-040052W
Pretty Love Beaded Butt Plug BI-040052W
Pretty Love Beaded Butt Plug BI-040052W
Pretty Love
Pretty Love Beaded Butt Plug BI-040052W
$127.99 $159.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Gender X Beaded Pleasure
Gender X Beaded Pleasure
Gender X Beaded Pleasure
Gender X Beaded Pleasure
Gender X
Gender X Beaded Pleasure
$139.99 $174.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Forto F-98R Rattler Plug Small Black
Forto
Forto F-98R Rattler Plug Small Black
$58.99
Forto F-35R Rattler T Plug One Size Green
Forto F-35R Rattler T Plug One Size Green
Forto F-35R Rattler T Plug One Size Green
Forto
Forto F-35R Rattler T Plug One Size Green
$59.99
Gender X Tunnel Tapper
Gender X Tunnel Tapper
Gender X Tunnel Tapper
Gender X Tunnel Tapper
Gender X Tunnel Tapper
Gender X Tunnel Tapper
Gender X Tunnel Tapper
Gender X Tunnel Tapper
Gender X Tunnel Tapper
Gender X Tunnel Tapper
Gender X
Gender X Tunnel Tapper
$155.99 $194.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Evolved Black Gem Anal Plug Medium
Evolved Black Gem Anal Plug Medium
Evolved Black Gem Anal Plug Medium
Evolved Black Gem Anal Plug Medium
Evolved Black Gem Anal Plug Medium
Evolved
Evolved Black Gem Anal Plug Medium
$46.39 $57.99
SALE
Gender X Ins and Outss
Gender X Ins and Outss
Gender X Ins and Outss
Gender X Ins and Outss
Gender X Ins and Outss
Gender X
Gender X Ins and Outss
$127.99 $159.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Gender X Lustrous Galaxy Wand
Gender X Lustrous Galaxy Wand
Gender X Lustrous Galaxy Wand
Gender X Lustrous Galaxy Wand
Gender X
Gender X Lustrous Galaxy Wand
$107.99 $134.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
ZT Plug & Tug
ZT Plug & Tug
ZT Plug & Tug
ZT Plug & Tug
ZT Plug & Tug
ZT Plug & Tug
ZT Plug & Tug
Zero Tolerance
ZT Plug & Tug
$132.79 $165.99 + Free Shipping
SALE

Find a Store Near You

Peaches & Cream is 100% Kiwi owned and operated with 10 stores nationwide to date. View Locations

Don’t Forget the Essentials

Shop Lube Shop Toy Cleaner Shop Condoms

Play Now, Pay Later


With Laybuy or Afterpay.