Butt Plugs

141 Products
Zero Tolerance Forever Anal
Zero Tolerance Forever Anal
Zero Tolerance Forever Anal
Zero Tolerance Forever Anal
Zero Tolerance Forever Anal
Zero Tolerance Forever Anal
Zero Tolerance Forever Anal
Zero Tolerance
Zero Tolerance Forever Anal
$95.99 $119.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Pretty Love Merlin Pink
Pretty Love Merlin Pink
Pretty Love Merlin Pink
Pretty Love Merlin Pink
Pretty Love Merlin Pink
Pretty Love Merlin Pink
Pretty Love
Pretty Love Merlin Pink
$140.79 $175.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Zero Tolerance Titan Anal Plug
Zero Tolerance Titan Anal Plug
Zero Tolerance Titan Anal Plug
Zero Tolerance Titan Anal Plug
Zero Tolerance Titan Anal Plug
Zero Tolerance Titan Anal Plug
Zero Tolerance Titan Anal Plug
Zero Tolerance Titan Anal Plug
Zero Tolerance
Zero Tolerance Titan Anal Plug
$124.79 $155.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Forto F-21 Plug Red Large
Forto F-21 Plug Red Large
Forto F-21 Plug Red Large
Forto F-21 Plug Red Large
Forto F-21 Plug Red Large
Forto F-21 Plug Red Large
Forto
Forto F-21 Plug Red Large
$89.99 + Free Shipping
Gender X The General
Gender X The General
Gender X The General
Gender X The General
Gender X
Gender X The General
$211.99 $264.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Playboy Pleasure Spinning Tail Teaser
Playboy Pleasure Spinning Tail Teaser
Playboy Pleasure Spinning Tail Teaser
Playboy Pleasure Spinning Tail Teaser
Playboy Pleasure Spinning Tail Teaser
Playboy
Playboy Pleasure Spinning Tail Teaser
$164.79 $205.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Playboy Pleasure Plug & Play
Playboy Pleasure Plug & Play
Playboy Pleasure Plug & Play
Playboy Pleasure Plug & Play
Playboy Pleasure Plug & Play
Playboy
Playboy Pleasure Plug & Play
$164.79 $205.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Playboy Pleasure Pleasure 3 Ways
Playboy Pleasure Pleasure 3 Ways
Playboy Pleasure Pleasure 3 Ways
Playboy Pleasure Pleasure 3 Ways
Playboy
Playboy Pleasure Pleasure 3 Ways
$145.59 $181.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Evolved Advance Metal Plug
Evolved Advance Metal Plug
Evolved Advance Metal Plug
Evolved Advance Metal Plug
Evolved Advance Metal Plug
Evolved
Evolved Advance Metal Plug
$141.59 $176.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Evolved Beginner Metal Plug
Evolved Beginner Metal Plug
Evolved Beginner Metal Plug
Evolved Beginner Metal Plug
Evolved Beginner Metal Plug
Evolved
Evolved Beginner Metal Plug
$129.59 $161.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Gender X Crystal Ball
Gender X Crystal Ball
Gender X Crystal Ball
Gender X Crystal Ball
Gender X Crystal Ball
Gender X
Gender X Crystal Ball
$121.59 $151.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Gender X Pink Paradise
Gender X Pink Paradise
Gender X Pink Paradise
Gender X Pink Paradise
Gender X
Gender X Pink Paradise
$163.99 $204.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Adam & Eve Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug Set
Adam & Eve Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug Set
Adam & Eve Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug Set
Adam & Eve Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug Set
Adam & Eve
Adam & Eve Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug Set
$163.99 $204.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Adam & Eve Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug - Large
Adam & Eve Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug - Large
Adam & Eve Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug - Large
Adam & Eve Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug - Large
Adam & Eve
Adam & Eve Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug - Large
$71.19 $88.99
SALE
Adam & Eve Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug - Medium
Adam & Eve Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug - Medium
Adam & Eve Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug - Medium
Adam & Eve Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug - Medium
Adam & Eve
Adam & Eve Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug - Medium
$63.19 $78.99
SALE
Gender X Orange Dream
Gender X Orange Dream
Gender X Orange Dream
Gender X Orange Dream
Gender X
Gender X Orange Dream
$163.99 $204.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Gender X Electric Blue
Gender X Electric Blue
Gender X Electric Blue
Gender X Electric Blue
Gender X
Gender X Electric Blue
$163.99 $204.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Gender X Ring Pop
Gender X Ring Pop
Gender X Ring Pop
Gender X Ring Pop
Gender X
Gender X Ring Pop
$130.39 $162.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Gender X Black Pearl
Gender X Black Pearl
Gender X Black Pearl
Gender X Black Pearl
Gender X
Gender X Black Pearl
$65.59 $81.99
SALE
Gender X The Baller
Gender X The Baller
Gender X The Baller
Gender X The Baller
Gender X
Gender X The Baller
$66.39 $82.99
SALE
Adam & Eve Rear Rocker Vibrating Glass Plug
Adam & Eve Rear Rocker Vibrating Glass Plug
Adam & Eve Rear Rocker Vibrating Glass Plug
Adam & Eve Rear Rocker Vibrating Glass Plug
Adam & Eve
Adam & Eve Rear Rocker Vibrating Glass Plug
$171.19 $213.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Evolved Joy Sticks
Evolved Joy Sticks
Evolved Joy Sticks
Evolved Joy Sticks
Evolved
Evolved Joy Sticks
$159.99 $199.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Gender X Gold Digger Plug Set
Gender X Gold Digger Plug Set
Gender X Gold Digger Plug Set
Gender X Gold Digger Plug Set
Gender X
Gender X Gold Digger Plug Set
$151.99 $189.99 + Free Shipping
SALE
Evolved Rainbow Metal Plug Set 3pk
Evolved Rainbow Metal Plug Set 3pk
Evolved Rainbow Metal Plug Set 3pk
Evolved Rainbow Metal Plug Set 3pk
Evolved Rainbow Metal Plug Set 3pk
Evolved
Evolved Rainbow Metal Plug Set 3pk
$147.99 $184.99 + Free Shipping
SALE

Find a Store Near You

Peaches & Cream is 100% Kiwi owned and operated with 10 stores nationwide to date. View Locations

Don’t Forget the Essentials

Shop Lube Shop Toy Cleaner Shop Condoms

Play Now, Pay Later


With Laybuy or Afterpay.