Butt Plugs

124 Products
Baile Butt Plug Purp 17001R
Buy Now
$24.99
Baile Butt Plug Purp 17001R
Glass anal plug with a pink gemstone on a white background
Buy Now
$44.50 $88.99
Pink Gem Glass Butt Plug Large
-50%
Pretty Love Twist Butt Plug - 200
Buy Now
$59.99
Pretty Love Twist Butt Plug - 200
Buttock plug with a red heart-shaped gem on a white background
Buy Now
$44.50 $88.99
Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug Large
-50%
Pretty Love Anal Balls - 040035
Buy Now
$44.99
Pretty Love Anal Balls - 040035
A matte black silicone butt plug with a flared base, shown against a plain white background. The brand name 'LOVENSE' is debossed on the base.
Buy Now
$384.99 with Free Shipping
Lovense Hush 2 App-Controlled Silicone Vibrating Butt Plug 1.75"
Pretty Love Anal Balls BI-040034
Buy Now
$44.99
Pretty Love Anal Balls BI-040034
Pretty Love Anal Plug Rechargeable BI-040067
Buy Now
$94.99
Pretty Love Anal Plug Rechargeable BI-040067
Pretty Love Mr Play Vibrating Anal Plug - 82-MR Black
Buy Now
$100.99 with Free Shipping
Pretty Love Mr Play Vibrating Anal Plug - 82-MR Black
Silicone Anal Ball - 33
Buy Now
$44.99
Silicone Anal Ball - 33
Ouch Beaded 4.6" Anal Plug Rose Gold
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch Beaded 4.6" Anal Plug Rose Gold
Gender X Gold Digger Plug Large
Buy Now
$84.99
Gender X Gold Digger Plug Large
Ouch 3.5" Anal Plug Rose Gold
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch 3.5" Anal Plug Rose Gold
Pleasure 3 Ways Butt Plug Set
Buy Now
$181.99 with Free Shipping
Pleasure 3 Ways Butt Plug Set
MR PLAY butt plug packaging with blue design on a white background
Buy Now
$29.99
Mr Play Butt Plug With Loop M
Spinning Tail Teaser Butt Plug
Buy Now
$205.99 with Free Shipping
Spinning Tail Teaser Butt Plug
Ouch Round Gem Butt Plug Small Gun Metal/Diamond
Buy Now
$34.99
Ouch Round Gem Butt Plug Small Gun Metal/Diamond
ZT Plug & Tug
Buy Now
$165.99 with Free Shipping
ZT Plug & Tug
Zero Tolerance Blue Oasis
Buy Now
$83.99
Zero Tolerance Blue Oasis
Lovetoy Legendary King-Sized Anal Bomber 9″ Butt Plug
Buy Now
$112.99 with Free Shipping
Lovetoy Legendary King-Sized Anal Bomber 9″ Butt Plug
Selopa Black Beauty
Buy Now
$121.99 with Free Shipping
Selopa Black Beauty
Evolved Lieutenant Vibrating Butt Plug
Buy Now
$80.99
Evolved Lieutenant Vibrating Butt Plug
MR PLAY butt plug packaging with blue silicone product on a white background
Buy Now
$39.99
Mr Play Butt Plug With Loop S
Gender X Dual Defender
Buy Now
$276.99 with Free Shipping
Gender X Dual Defender
Selopa The Colonel
Buy Now
$121.99 with Free Shipping
Selopa The Colonel
Ouch P-Spot 4.6" Anal Plug Metallic Purple
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch P-Spot 4.6" Anal Plug Metallic Purple
Ouch P-spot 4.6" Anal Plug Gun Metal
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch P-spot 4.6" Anal Plug Gun Metal
Lovense Hush 2 - 1"
Buy Now
$349.99 with Free Shipping
Lovense Hush 2 - 1"
Evolved Luminous Plug Large Green - Glow in the Dark
Buy Now
$79.99
Evolved Luminous Plug Large Green - Glow in the Dark
Running Wild White Tail
Buy Now
$59.99
Running Wild White Tail
Zero Tolerance Tip To Tail
Buy Now
$181.99 with Free Shipping
Zero Tolerance Tip To Tail
Loveline Velvet Butt Plug Blue
Buy Now
$95.99
Loveline Velvet Butt Plug Blue
Ouch Curvy Anal Plug 4.6" Metallic Blue
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch Curvy Anal Plug 4.6" Metallic Blue
Ouch 3.5 Inches Anal Plug Gun Metal
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch 3.5 Inches Anal Plug Gun Metal
Gender X Back It Up
Buy Now
$218.99 with Free Shipping
Gender X Back It Up
Gender X Ball Game
Buy Now
$269.99 with Free Shipping
Gender X Ball Game

Find a Store Near You

Peaches & Cream is 100% Kiwi owned and operated with 10 stores nationwide to date. View Locations

Don’t Forget the Essentials

Shop Lube Shop Toy Cleaner Shop Condoms Shop Storage

Play Now, Pay Later


In four interest-free payments with Afterpay.