Butt Plugs

136 Products
Adam & Eve Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug Medium
$45.99 $78.99
Adam & Eve Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug Medium
SALE
Pretty Love Beginners Mini Anal Kit 3pc - 456H
$64.99
Pretty Love Beginners Mini Anal Kit 3pc - 456H
Pretty Love Anal Stim BI-040036N
$29.99
Pretty Love Anal Stim BI-040036N
Pretty Love Anal Stim BI-040040
$49.99
Pretty Love Anal Stim BI-040040
Adam & Eve Pink Gem Anal Plug Large
$53.99
Adam & Eve Pink Gem Anal Plug Large
Pretty Love Special Anal Stimulation Butt Plug w Remote - 038
$54.99
Pretty Love Special Anal Stimulation Butt Plug w Remote - 038
Pretty Love Butt Plug BI-040039N
$39.99
Pretty Love Butt Plug BI-040039N
Adam & Eve Clear Gem Anal Plug Large
$34.99 $54.99
Adam & Eve Clear Gem Anal Plug Large
SALE
Evolved Black Gem Anal Plug Set 3pk
$144.99 with Free Shipping
Evolved Black Gem Anal Plug Set 3pk
Evolved Get Your Groove On
$74.99
Evolved Get Your Groove On
Pretty Love Silicone Butt Plug - 40N
$29.99
Pretty Love Silicone Butt Plug - 40N
Adam & Eve Pink Gem Glass Large
$49.99 $88.99
Adam & Eve Pink Gem Glass Large
SALE
Adam & Eve Vibrating Bumpy Bead Set
$154.99 with Free Shipping
Adam & Eve Vibrating Bumpy Bead Set
Love toy Lure Me Butt Plug Slim - BK18S
$29.99
Love toy Lure Me Butt Plug Slim - BK18S
Pretty Love Anal Stim BI-040036
$54.99
Pretty Love Anal Stim BI-040036
Selopa Intro to Plugs
$59.99
Selopa Intro to Plugs
Ouch Anal Plug 3.1" Rose Gold
$29.99
Ouch Anal Plug 3.1" Rose Gold
Ouch Anal Plug 2.6" Metallic BLUE
$25.99
Ouch Anal Plug 2.6" Metallic BLUE
Pretty Love Mr Play Vibrating Anal Plug - 82-MR Black
$100.99 with Free Shipping
Pretty Love Mr Play Vibrating Anal Plug - 82-MR Black
Evolved Mighty Mini Plug Rechargeable
$119.99 with Free Shipping
Evolved Mighty Mini Plug Rechargeable
Gender X Lustrous Galaxy Wand
$134.99 with Free Shipping
Gender X Lustrous Galaxy Wand
Ouch 3.5" Anal Plug Metallic Blue
$39.99
Ouch 3.5" Anal Plug Metallic Blue
Playboy Pleasure Pleasure 3 Ways Butt Plug Set
$181.99 with Free Shipping
Playboy Pleasure Pleasure 3 Ways Butt Plug Set
Pretty Love Sensitive Prostate Plug - 459
$44.99
Pretty Love Sensitive Prostate Plug - 459

Find a Store Near You

Peaches & Cream is 100% Kiwi owned and operated with 10 stores nationwide to date. View Locations

Don’t Forget the Essentials

Shop Lube Shop Toy Cleaner Shop Condoms

Play Now, Pay Later


In four interest-free payments with Afterpay.