Butt Plugs

225 Products
Gender X Lustrous Galaxy Wand
Buy Now
$107.99 $134.99 with Free Shipping
Gender X Lustrous Galaxy Wand
SALE
Pretty Love Anal Plug Rechargeable BI-040067
Buy Now
$75.99 $94.99
Pretty Love Anal Plug Rechargeable BI-040067
SALE
Pretty Love Anal Balls BI-040034
Buy Now
$35.99 $44.99
Pretty Love Anal Balls BI-040034
SALE
Pretty Love Vibe Lynn
Buy Now
$51.99 $64.99
Pretty Love Vibe Lynn
SALE
Ouch Beaded Anal Plug 4.6" Purple
Buy Now
$31.99 $39.99
Ouch Beaded Anal Plug 4.6" Purple
SALE
Pretty Love Mr Play Vibrating Anal Plug - 82-MR Black
Buy Now
$80.79 $100.99
Pretty Love Mr Play Vibrating Anal Plug - 82-MR Black
SALE
Realrock 3.5" Crystal Clear Plug Clear
Buy Now
$27.19 $33.99
Realrock 3.5" Crystal Clear Plug Clear
SALE
Realrock 4.5" Crystal Clear Plug Clear
Buy Now
$27.99 $34.99
Realrock 4.5" Crystal Clear Plug Clear
SALE
Blue packaging of MR PLAY slim anal plug with product details on a white background
Buy Now
$19.99 $24.99
Mr Play Slim Anal Plug S
SALE
Evolved Rainbow Metal Plug Small
Buy Now
$47.99 $59.99
Evolved Rainbow Metal Plug Small
SALE
Ouch Beaded 4.6" Anal Plug Rose Gold
Buy Now
$31.99 $39.99
Ouch Beaded 4.6" Anal Plug Rose Gold
SALE
Gender X Gold Digger Plug Large
Buy Now
$67.99 $84.99
Gender X Gold Digger Plug Large
SALE
Playboy Pleasure Pleasure 3 Ways Butt Plug Set
Buy Now
$145.59 $181.99 with Free Shipping
Playboy Pleasure Pleasure 3 Ways Butt Plug Set
SALE
ZT Plug & Tug
Buy Now
$132.79 $165.99 with Free Shipping
ZT Plug & Tug
SALE
Playboy Jewels Beads Glass Butt Plug
Buy Now
$71.99 $89.99
Playboy Jewels Beads Glass Butt Plug
SALE
Pretty Love Hanson Butt Plug BI-040161Q
Buy Now
$66.39 $82.99
Pretty Love Hanson Butt Plug BI-040161Q
SALE
Adam & Eve Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug - Large
Buy Now
$44.50 $88.99
Adam & Eve Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug - Large
SALE
MR PLAY butt plug packaging with blue design on a white background
Buy Now
$23.99 $29.99
Mr Play Butt Plug With Loop M
SALE
Silicone Anal Ball - 33
Buy Now
$35.99 $44.99
Silicone Anal Ball - 33
SALE
Lovetoy Legendary King-Sized Anal Bomber 9″ Butt Plug
Buy Now
$90.39 $112.99
Lovetoy Legendary King-Sized Anal Bomber 9″ Butt Plug
SALE
Pretty Love Sensitive Prostate Plug - 459
Buy Now
$35.99 $44.99
Pretty Love Sensitive Prostate Plug - 459
SALE
We Vibe Ditto+ Pink
Buy Now
$168.79 $210.99 with Free Shipping
We Vibe Ditto+ Pink
SALE
Realrock 4.5" Crystal Clear Plug Black
Buy Now
$27.99 $34.99
Realrock 4.5" Crystal Clear Plug Black
SALE
Realrock 4.5" Crystal Clear Plug Purple
Buy Now
$27.99 $34.99
Realrock 4.5" Crystal Clear Plug Purple
SALE

Find a Store Near You

Peaches & Cream is 100% Kiwi owned and operated with 10 stores nationwide to date. View Locations

Don’t Forget the Essentials

Shop Lube Shop Toy Cleaner Shop Condoms

Play Now, Pay Later


In four interest-free payments with Afterpay.