Butt Plugs

194 Products
Trust The Thrust Vibrating Thrusting Butt Plug
Buy Now
$269.99 with Free Shipping
Trust The Thrust Vibrating Thrusting Butt Plug
Selopa The Colonel
Buy Now
$121.99 with Free Shipping
Selopa The Colonel
Ouch P-spot 4.6" Anal Plug Gun Metal
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch P-spot 4.6" Anal Plug Gun Metal
Gender X The Baller
Buy Now
$82.99
Gender X The Baller
Evolved Luminous Plug Large Green - Glow in the Dark
Buy Now
$79.99
Evolved Luminous Plug Large Green - Glow in the Dark
Running Wild White Tail
Buy Now
$59.99
Running Wild White Tail
Running Wild Pink Bunny Tail
Buy Now
$49.99
Running Wild Pink Bunny Tail
Zero Tolerance Tip To Tail
Buy Now
$181.99 with Free Shipping
Zero Tolerance Tip To Tail
Realrock 4.5" Crystal Clear Plug Blue
Buy Now
$34.99
Realrock 4.5" Crystal Clear Plug Blue
MR PLAY butt plug packaging with blue silicone product on a white background
Buy Now
$39.99
Mr Play Butt Plug With Loop S
Selopa Black Beauty
Buy Now
$121.99 with Free Shipping
Selopa Black Beauty
Love Toy Metal Plug RO-SL07 Blue/Silver
Buy Now
$75.99
Love Toy Metal Plug RO-SL07 Blue/Silver
Pretty Love Beaded Butt Plug BI-040052W
Buy Now
$159.99 with Free Shipping
Pretty Love Beaded Butt Plug BI-040052W
Loveline Velvet Butt Plug Blue
Buy Now
$95.99
Loveline Velvet Butt Plug Blue
Pretty Love Sturdy Silicone Anal Plug - 460
Buy Now
$59.99
Pretty Love Sturdy Silicone Anal Plug - 460
Ouch Paris Metal Butt Plug Set Blue
Buy Now
$139.99 with Free Shipping
Ouch Paris Metal Butt Plug Set Blue
Gender X Dual Defender
Buy Now
$276.99 with Free Shipping
Gender X Dual Defender
Tux Aluminum Metal Butt Plug Large
Buy Now
$78.99
Tux Aluminum Metal Butt Plug Large
Ouch P-Spot 4.6" Anal Plug Metallic Purple
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch P-Spot 4.6" Anal Plug Metallic Purple
Ouch Curvy Anal Plug 4.6" Metallic Blue
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch Curvy Anal Plug 4.6" Metallic Blue
Gender X Teamwork Butt Plug and Cock Ring
Buy Now
$349.99 with Free Shipping
Gender X Teamwork Butt Plug and Cock Ring
Gender X Ball Game
Buy Now
$269.99 with Free Shipping
Gender X Ball Game
Lovense Hush 2 - 1"
Buy Now
$349.99 with Free Shipping
Lovense Hush 2 - 1"
Spinning Tail Teaser Butt Plug
Buy Now
$205.99 with Free Shipping
Spinning Tail Teaser Butt Plug
Pretty Love Mr Play Inflatable Anal Plug - 66W-MR Black
Buy Now
$180.99 with Free Shipping
Pretty Love Mr Play Inflatable Anal Plug - 66W-MR Black
Zero Tolerance The Emperor Rechargeable Plug with Remote
Buy Now
$139.99 with Free Shipping
Zero Tolerance The Emperor Rechargeable Plug with Remote
Forto F-98R Rattler Plug Small Green
Buy Now
$58.99
Forto F-98R Rattler Plug Small Green
Running Wild Brown Tail
Buy Now
$59.99
Running Wild Brown Tail
Evolved Paradise Butt Plug
Buy Now
$149.99 with Free Shipping
Evolved Paradise Butt Plug
Levelz Remote Control Beaded Vibrating Silicone Anal Plug Black
Buy Now
$119.99 with Free Shipping
Levelz Remote Control Beaded Vibrating Silicone Anal Plug Black
Levelz inflatable anal plug packaging on a white background
Buy Now
$139.99 with Free Shipping
Levelz Beaded Inflatable Silicone Anal Plug
Pretty Love Butt Plug Massager BI-040045
Buy Now
$99.99
Pretty Love Butt Plug Massager BI-040045
We Vibe Ditto+ Black
Buy Now
$210.99 with Free Shipping
We Vibe Ditto+ Black
Evolved The Flapper Vibrating Anal Plug with Flapping Shaft
Buy Now
$185.99 with Free Shipping
Evolved The Flapper Vibrating Anal Plug with Flapping Shaft
Pretty Love Magic Jingers Plug BI014595W
Buy Now
$189.99 with Free Shipping
Pretty Love Magic Jingers Plug BI014595W
Ouch Venice Metal Butt Plug Set Iridesce
Buy Now
$139.99 with Free Shipping
Ouch Venice Metal Butt Plug Set Iridesce

Find a Store Near You

Peaches & Cream is 100% Kiwi owned and operated with 10 stores nationwide to date. View Locations

Don’t Forget the Essentials

Shop Lube Shop Toy Cleaner Shop Condoms Shop Storage

Play Now, Pay Later


In four interest-free payments with Afterpay.