Butt Plugs

124 Products
Gender X Pink Paradise
Buy Now
$204.99 with Free Shipping
Gender X Pink Paradise
Gender X Gold Digger Plug Set
Buy Now
$189.99 with Free Shipping
Gender X Gold Digger Plug Set
Evolved Rainbow Metal Plug Set 3pk
Buy Now
$184.99 with Free Shipping
Evolved Rainbow Metal Plug Set 3pk
Zero Tolerance Everest
Buy Now
$155.99 with Free Shipping
Zero Tolerance Everest
Evolved Creamsicle
Buy Now
$139.99 with Free Shipping
Evolved Creamsicle
Revelz large hexagonal vibrating anal plug packaging on a white background
Buy Now
$159.99 with Free Shipping
Levelz Hexagonal Vibrating Silicone Anal Plug Large Black
Levelz small hexagonal vibrating anal plug packaging on a white background
Buy Now
$149.99 with Free Shipping
Levelz Hexagonal Vibrating Silicone Anal Plug Small Black
Levelz Hexagonal Vibrating Silicone Anal Plug Medium Teal
Buy Now
$169.99 with Free Shipping
Levelz Hexagonal Vibrating Silicone Anal Plug Medium Teal
Levelz Ribbed Inflatable Silicone Anal Plug Black
Buy Now
$139.99 with Free Shipping
Levelz Ribbed Inflatable Silicone Anal Plug Black
Gender X Rockin Metal Plug Mini
Buy Now
$184.99 with Free Shipping
Gender X Rockin Metal Plug Mini
Blue packaging of a dual motor beaded vibrating anal plug with visible brand name.
Buy Now
$179.99 with Free Shipping
Levelz Dual Motor Remote Control Beaded Vibrating Liquid Silicone Prostate Stimulator Teal
Boxed vibrating anal plug with remote control on a white background
Buy Now
$139.99 with Free Shipping
Levelz Remote Control Vibrating Liquid Silicone Anal Plug Black
Blue butt plug packaging with 'MR. PLAY' branding on a white background
Buy Now
$49.99
Mr Play Butt Plug With Loop L
MR PLAY product packaging on a white background
Buy Now
$59.99
Mr Play Slim Anal Plug XL
Lovetoy Mystitail Black
Buy Now
$85.99
Lovetoy Mystitail Black
Lovetoy Mystitail Purple
Buy Now
$85.99
Lovetoy Mystitail Purple
Evolved Hole Punch Butt Plug Set
Buy Now
$159.99 with Free Shipping
Evolved Hole Punch Butt Plug Set
Evolved Backdoor Banger
Buy Now
$254.99 with Free Shipping
Evolved Backdoor Banger
ZT Shape Shifter Butt Plug
Buy Now
$277.99 with Free Shipping
ZT Shape Shifter Butt Plug
Zero Tolerance Forever Anal
Buy Now
$119.99 with Free Shipping
Zero Tolerance Forever Anal
Pretty Love Merlin Pink
Buy Now
$175.99 with Free Shipping
Pretty Love Merlin Pink
Pretty Love Butt Plug Push Over 040076
Buy Now
$89.99
Pretty Love Butt Plug Push Over 040076
Forto Curved Vibrating Anal Plug Blue
Buy Now
$149.99 with Free Shipping
Forto Curved Vibrating Anal Plug Blue
Forto F-30 Plug Black Large
Buy Now
$70.99
Forto F-30 Plug Black Large
Ouch New York Metal Butt Plug Set Silver
Buy Now
$159.99 with Free Shipping
Ouch New York Metal Butt Plug Set Silver
Ouch Fashionable Butt Plug Pink
Buy Now
$134.99 with Free Shipping
Ouch Fashionable Butt Plug Pink
Ouch Fashionable Butt Plug Purple
Buy Now
$134.99 with Free Shipping
Ouch Fashionable Butt Plug Purple
Ouch Oblong Anal Plug 4.6" Metallic Blue
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch Oblong Anal Plug 4.6" Metallic Blue
Ouch 4.6" Oval Anal Plug Rose Gold
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch 4.6" Oval Anal Plug Rose Gold
Ouch Finger Anal Plug 4.6" Rose Gold
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch Finger Anal Plug 4.6" Rose Gold
Ouch Curvy Anal Plug 4.6" Rose Gold
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch Curvy Anal Plug 4.6" Rose Gold
Ouch Curvy Anal Plug 4.6" Metallic Purple
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch Curvy Anal Plug 4.6" Metallic Purple
Ouch Ribbed Anal Plug 4.6" Metallic Purple
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch Ribbed Anal Plug 4.6" Metallic Purple
Ouch Finger Anal Plug 4.6" Metallic Purple
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch Finger Anal Plug 4.6" Metallic Purple
Ouch Oval 4.6" Anal Plug Metallic Blue
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch Oval 4.6" Anal Plug Metallic Blue
Ouch Ribbed Anal Plug 4.6" Metallic Blue
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch Ribbed Anal Plug 4.6" Metallic Blue

Find a Store Near You

Peaches & Cream is 100% Kiwi owned and operated with 10 stores nationwide to date. View Locations

Don’t Forget the Essentials

Shop Lube Shop Toy Cleaner Shop Condoms Shop Storage

Play Now, Pay Later


In four interest-free payments with Afterpay.