Butt Plugs

216 Products
Pretty Love Merlin Plug
Buy Now
$169.99 with Free Shipping
Pretty Love Merlin Plug
Pretty Love Butt Plug Push Over 040076
Buy Now
$89.99
Pretty Love Butt Plug Push Over 040076
Forto Curved Vibrating Anal Plug Blue
Buy Now
$149.99 with Free Shipping
Forto Curved Vibrating Anal Plug Blue
Forto Pointed Vibrating Anal Plug Green
Buy Now
$149.99 with Free Shipping
Forto Pointed Vibrating Anal Plug Green
Forto Curved Vibrating Anal Plug Black
Buy Now
$149.99 with Free Shipping
Forto Curved Vibrating Anal Plug Black
Forto Vibrating Anal Plug Blue
Buy Now
$149.99 with Free Shipping
Forto Vibrating Anal Plug Blue
Forto F-30 Plug Black Large
Buy Now
$70.99
Forto F-30 Plug Black Large
Ouch Curvy Anal Plug 4.6" Gun Metal
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch Curvy Anal Plug 4.6" Gun Metal
Ouch New York Metal Butt Plug Set Silver
Buy Now
$159.99 with Free Shipping
Ouch New York Metal Butt Plug Set Silver
Pretty Love Beaded Rotating Plug Black w Remote Control
Buy Now
$179.99 with Free Shipping
Pretty Love Beaded Rotating Plug Black w Remote Control
Ouch Fashionable Butt Plug Pink
Buy Now
$134.99 with Free Shipping
Ouch Fashionable Butt Plug Pink
Ouch Fashionable Butt Plug Purple
Buy Now
$134.99 with Free Shipping
Ouch Fashionable Butt Plug Purple
Pretty Love Heather Plug BI-014647W
Buy Now
$169.99 with Free Shipping
Pretty Love Heather Plug BI-014647W
Gender X Dual Defender
Buy Now
$276.99 with Free Shipping
Gender X Dual Defender
Gender X Double My Pleasure
Buy Now
$243.99 with Free Shipping
Gender X Double My Pleasure
Evolved Paradise Butt Plug
Buy Now
$149.99 with Free Shipping
Evolved Paradise Butt Plug
Gender X The General
Buy Now
$264.99 with Free Shipping
Gender X The General
Whipsmart 14" Black Foxtail Butt Plug
Buy Now
$139.99 with Free Shipping
Whipsmart 14" Black Foxtail Butt Plug
Whipsmart Black Bunny Tail Butt plug
Buy Now
$89.99
Whipsmart Black Bunny Tail Butt plug
Evolved Twisted Love
Buy Now
$149.99 with Free Shipping
Evolved Twisted Love
Zero Tolerance Bubble Butt
Buy Now
$279.99 with Free Shipping
Zero Tolerance Bubble Butt
Ouch Oblong Anal Plug 4.6" Metallic Blue
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch Oblong Anal Plug 4.6" Metallic Blue
Ouch Ribbed Anal Plug 4.6" Rose Gold
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch Ribbed Anal Plug 4.6" Rose Gold
Ouch 4.6" Oval Anal Plug Rose Gold
Buy Now
$39.99
Ouch 4.6" Oval Anal Plug Rose Gold

Find a Store Near You

Peaches & Cream is 100% Kiwi owned and operated with 10 stores nationwide to date. View Locations

Don’t Forget the Essentials

Shop Lube Shop Toy Cleaner Shop Condoms

Play Now, Pay Later


In four interest-free payments with Afterpay.